Re: (test) Re: Mot cach nhin doi dang so; ca'ch "phe ^bi`nh" cu?a TMH

[Dinh Van An <divan@presto.phys.sci.osaka-u.ac.jp>]

Hi ba'c HL,
 Ca?m o+n ba'c dda~ tra? lo+`i. 

Hoang Linh wrote:
> 
> Hi ba'c An,
> Ca'm o+n ba'c dda~ qua' khen. To^i cu~ng muo^'n vie^'t cho he^'t nhe~ ve^`
> "Co+ ho^.i cu?a Chu'a", nhu+ng pha?i suy nghi~ cho ky~ dda~, ba'c a.. Va`,
> ddo' chi? la` va`i nha^.n xe't nga('n cu?a to^i, khi to^i ddo.c mo^.t msg
> cu?a mo^.t ba'c (co' dda? ddo^.ng dde^'n TMH), chu+' thu+.c ra toî dda~
> ddo.c bai vie^'t la`n na`y cu?a o^ng ta dda^u, ma` da'm no'i can?

   The^' thi` to^i pha?i ddo+.i ba'c ddo.c xong ba`i phe^ bi`nh cu?a TMH
ro^`i mo+'i ddu+o+.c ddo.c ba`i "Phe^ bi`nh TMH" cu?a ba'c dda^y-:))).
Ba'c cu+' ddo.c tu+` tu+` ro^`i vie^'t sau cu~ng ddu+o+.c. To^i thi'ch
su+. pha'n xe't co' ca+n cu+' chu+' cu+' du+.a va`o va`i ba ca^u hay
va`i ddoa.n va+n  ho+' he^nh cu?a mo^.t ngu+o+`i ma` cho ngu+o+`i ta
do^'t na't thi` to^i nghi~ la` qua' vo^.i va~.  
 
  
> DDu'ng la` "TMH dda~ co' tho+`i ga^y so'ng gio' tre^n "chie^'n tru+o+`ng"
> phe^ bi`nh VH cu?a VN" nhu+ ba'c vie^'t. Tha^.m chi^', hie^.n nay o^ng a^'y
> va^~n tie^'p tu.c "ga^y so'ng gio'", ne^'u co' di.p.
> 
> Nhu+ng, cu+' "ga^y so'ng gio'" kho^ng nha^'t thie^'t pha?i co' nghi~a la`
> o^ng a^'y gio?i ve^` phe^ bi`nh va` ly' lua^.n. To^i nghi~ ne^n tri'ch sau
> dda^y y' kie^'n cu?a mo^.t ngu+o+`i o+? nha` (mo^.t tha`y gia'o), vi' TMH
> nhu+ mo^.t ca^`u thu? bo'ng dda' to^`i, nhu+ng toa`n nhe` cha^n ca'c danh
> thu? ma` dda'. Nhu+ the^' cu~ng co' the^? "ga^y so'ng gio'" nhu+
> thu+o+`ng...

  To^i  ho+i kha'c vo+'i o^ng tha^`y  ve^` ca'ch nhi`n ve^` "ga^y so'ng
gio'" tre^n va+n dda`n. 
 Giu+~a sa^n bo'ng ha.ng xoa`ng thi` co' the^? co' ca^`u thu? to^`i ga^y
so'ng gio' nhu+ng trong mo^.t ddo^.i bo'ng ta^`m co+~ thi` anh cha`ng
na`y(ne^'u co') se~ bi. mo+`i ddi nha+.t bo'ng cho ddo^`ng ddo^.i ta^.p
tru+o+'c khi bi. mo+`i ra kho?i ddo^.i hi`nh vi~nh vie^~n. 
 Va+n ho.c o+? ta^`m co+~ quo^'c gia khong pha?i la` xo' la`ng Vu~ DDa.i
dde^? ca'c chu' Chi' Phe`o tha ho^` chu+?i, mo^.t ke? do^'t na't kho^ng
the^? vie^'t ra ddu+o+.c nhu+~ng thu+' ga^y xo^n xao va+n dda`n chu+'
ddu+`ng no'i dde^'n chuye^.n ga^y  so'ng gio'. Muo^'n la`m Chi' Phe`o
trong va+n ho.c pha?i co' tri' tue^.  va` ta`i na+ng chu+' kho^ng pha?i
chi? ca^`n mo^.t ma?nh chai vo+~ la` ddu?. 
 Co' the^? nhu+ ba'c vie^'t: TMH ba^'t ca^.p trong phong ca'ch phe^
bi`nh cu?a mi`nh. DDie^?m na`y to^i nghi~ co' the^? co'. Nhu+ng "ra^'t
ke'm co?i" thi` ba'c ho+i...vo^.i cha+ng ?.
 
> No'i the^', kho^ng pha?i to^i co' y' ba?o "Co+ ho^.i cu?a Chu'a" la` mo^.t
> dda.i ta'c pha^?m. To^i chi? muo^'n no'i trong dda.i dda so^' ca'c tru+o+`ng
> ho+.p, ca'i lo^'i phe^ bi`nh kie^?u quy chu.p, phu. ho.a chi'nh quye^`n cu?a
> TMH, le~ ra ra^'t kho^ng ne^n co' o+? tho+`i nay.

  Ba'c HL o+i, to^i co' tha^'y chi'nh quye^`n le^n tie^'ng dda^u ma`
o^ng TMH phu. ho.a nhi?. 
 Tri`nh ddo^. ca?m thu. va+n ho.c nghe^. thua^.t cu?a to^i kho^ng
ddu+o+.c cao la+'m ne^n kho^ng da'm ba`n ky~ nhu+ng xem ra ba`i phe^
bi`nh cu?a TMH kho^ng pha?i la` thu+' ma` ba'c dde^` ca^.p dda^u.
Ma+.c du` to^i kho^ng co' ddu+o+.c ca'i ca?m gia'c de^~ chi.u khi ddo.c
ba`i phe^ bi`nh na`y, nhu+ng va+n phong kho^ng co' mu`i bo^`i bu't. 
 To^i tu+`ng ddu+o+.c nghe ra+`ng va+n phe^ bi`nh cu?a TMH nhu+ phi?
ba'ng ngu+o+`i vie^'t, ddo.c ba`i na`y thi` mo+'i bie^'t-:)). The^'
nhu+ng kha'c vo+'i va`i ba'c dda~ nha^.n xe't, to^i kho^ng tha^'y ca'i
mu~ na`o trong tay TMH ca?. chi? tha^'y ca^y roi va` ca^y gia'o-:))) 
 
> To^i ddu+o+.c ddo.c tu+o+ng ddo^'i nhie^`u ba`i cu?a TMH, nhu+ng so+. ra(ng
> ne^'u vie^'t ra, thi` ddo' cu~ng va^~n chi? la` y' kie^'n cu?a ca' nha^n
> to^i tho^i, chu+' chu+?a cha('c dda~ tha^.t "xa'c dda'ng va` co' ca+n cu+'",
> va ca`ng kho^ng da'm la`m "cho anh em ddu+o+.c sa'ng ma+'t sa'ng ma`y" nhu+
> ba'c xui da.i. :-)) Tuy nhie^n, ne^'u co' di.p to^i cu~ng se~ xin vie^'t,
> chi? kho^ng bie^'t ne^'u ddi qua' sa^u vao nhu+~ng chi tie^'t nay, kha'c,
> co' vu+o+.t qua' khuo^n kho^? cho phe'p cu?a VNSA kho^ng tho^i.

   Ba'c a., tre^n VNSA na`y tha^.m chi' o+? ba^'t cu+' dda^u, nhu+~ng
sa?n pha^?m tri' tue^. dde^`u mang ti'nh chu? quan. Va^'n dde^` o+?
cho^~ la` ca'i chu? quan cu?a ngu+o;`i vie^'t co' cha?y cu`ng do`ng
vo+'i dda so^' ngu+o;`i ddo.c hay kho^ng, ca'i chu? quan ddo' co' la`
sa?n pha^?m cu?a tu+ duy logic du+.a tre^n ca'c cu+' lie^.u xa'c dda'ng
kho^ng. Ne^'u chi? la^'y thie^n kie^'n cu?a mi`nh dde^? pha'n da.y
ngu+o+`i kha'c thi` to^i cha+?ng mong ba'c vie^'t, nhu+ng qua nhu+~ng
ba`i vie^'t cu?a ba'c la^u nay to^i tin ba'c se~ kho^ng dde^? su+.
ddi.nh kie^'n na`o ddo' ne^'u co' bo'p me'o nhu+~ng nha^.n xe't cu?a
ba'c ve^` TMH. 
  La^u nay ca'i "chu? quan" cu?a ba'c co' ve? cha?y co' do`ng
dda^'y-:))))
 Ve^` khuo^n kho^? VNSA to^i cho la` ddang qua' ro^.ng cho dde^` ta`i
na`y ddo', cha+?ng le~ la.i co' ddie^`u gi` trong v/d ve^` TMH vu+o+.t
kho?i ca'i  khung co da~n cu?a VNSA na`y-:)))
  
 
> Du sao ddi nu+~a, to^i nghi~ ne^'u muo^'n dda'nh gia' ddu'ng ve^` TMH (con
> ngu+o+`i va "va(n nghie^.p"), ne^n ddo.c ca? nhu+~ng gi` TMH dda~ vie^'t
> tho+i xu+a (nhu+ "Ly tha^n" cha(?ng ha.n), va` ma^'y ta^.p sa'ch ly' lua^.n,
> phe^ binh cu?a o^ng a^'y, dda~ ddu+o+.c ca'c gia?i thu+o+?ng va(n ho.c o+?
> nha`, nhu+ "Tho+ pha?n tho+", "Phe^ binh pha?n phe^binh"..., va` ca'c ba`i
> TMH dda(ng ta?i o+? ra^'t nhie^`u ma(.t ba'o. La.i cu~ng ne^n ddo.c qua
> (ne^'u co' the^?) nhu+~ng ta'c pha^?m, ta'c gia? dda~ bi. TMH "dda'nh" (so^'
> na`y nhie^`u vo^ke^?!), vi` o^ng Ha?o cu~ng hay be? cong nhu+~ng gi`
> ngu+o+i kha'c no'i va` vie^'t la('m.

   DDo^`'ng y' vo+'i ba'c, dde^? dda'nh gia' ddu'ng ca^`n pha?i ddo.c
ky~.  Gia' nhu+ nhu+~ng ba`i ddo' dda~ ddu+o+.c lu+u tru+~ trong ma'y
cu?a ba'c (kho^ng ca^`n pha?i go~ nu+~a) thi` xin phe'p ba'c cho to^i
ddu+o+.c xem qua mo^.t chu't nhe'-:))
 
Ca?m o+n ba'c va` cho+` ddo.c ba`i vie^'t cu?a ba'c

-- 
Dinh Van An
URL:http://ann.phys.wani.osaka-u.ac.jp/~an/