Re: Nguye^n va(n ba`i ba'o ( Re : Tin toa` a'n )

[Nguyen Tuan <hoatuan@glasnet.ru>]

Hi ca'c ba'c !
 DDu'ng la` o^ng Tra^`n phu*o*ng Ky` na`y la` nha` khoa ho.c ne^n ma('c
pha?i sai la^`m ve^` qua?n ly' ta`i chi'nh .DDa`nh ra(`ng o^ng sai
nhu*ng a'n 10 na(m la` qua' na(.ng .KHo^ng bie^'t ca'c ba'c am hie^?u
lua^.t pha'p ,hay ba'c na`o co' cuo^'n "bo^.lua^.t hi`nh su*. thu*? tra
la.i xem to^.i "co^' y' la`m tra'i"`va` "ga^y ha^.u qua? ngie^m trong"
khung pha.t nhe. nha^'t va` na(.ng nha^'t la` bao nhie^u? (ma` cu~ng ky`
la. ba`i ba'o kho^ng tha^'y no'i ro~ to^.i na`y la` ddie^?m na`o? bao
nhie^u dde^? ngu*o*`i ta de^~ tra cu*'u) .Ca'c ba'c muo^'n be^nh vu*.c
cho o^ng TPK theo to^i thi` pha?i quan ta^m dde^'n nhu*`ng ddie^?m sau:
1/ la` pha?i nghie^n cu*'u xem xe't theo lua^.t pha'p hie^.n ha`nh VN
thi`nhu*~ng ha`nh vi cu?a o^ng TPK co' the^? ddo^?i ra to^.i danh kha'c
ddu*o*.c kho^ng ?To^.i na`o ddo' co' sai pha.m tu*o*ng tu*. nhu*ng mu*'c
a'n chi? khoa?ng 2-3 na(m tho^i .Sau ddo' ta se~ su*? du.ng dde^'n ca'c"
ti`nh tie^'t gia?m nhe. to^.i" vd nhu* co^'ng hie^'n KH ,hoa(.c KHO^NG
CO^' Y',va` ha~ng ta`i tro*. chi'nh kho^ng khie^'u na.i ....dde^? co'
the^? dde^` nghi. to`a cho "hu*o*?ng a'n treo"
2/ Du`ng du* lua^.n xa` ho^i.ga^y a'p lu*.c .Ca'i na`y co'the^? ke^u
go.i du* lua^.n ca? trong va` ngoa`i nu*o*'c,nhu*~ng nha` KH ,ca'c to^?
chu*'c ba?o ve^.quye^`n con ngu*o*`i ....ke^u go.i thie^.n chi' va` su*.
ddo^`ng ca?m ...pha?i vie^'t ddu*o*.c va`i ba`i ba'o dda(ng ca? trong
va` ngoa`i nu*o*'c,(ne^'u ca^`n thie^'t cu*? ba'c TP vie^'t thu* le^n
o^ng TDDL cu~ng ddu*o*.c)
3/ca^`n pha?i lo^i ca? UBND ti?nh QNDN va`o cuo^.c ,vi` mo^.t dde^` ta`i
ho. xe't duye^.t tru*o*'c va` sau ddo' chi'nh ho.tri`nh cho Toyota
duye^.t thi` ho. pha?i co' tra'ch nhie^.m theo do~i ,hu*o*'ng da^~n va`
qua?n ly'.Ne^'u co' sai pha.m thi` to^.i cu?a ho. cu~ng pha?i nhu* cu?a
o^ng Ky` ,vi` ho. co`n la` nhu*`ng ngu*o*`i chuye^n nghie^.p a(n lu*o*ng
ve^` qua?n ly' ,co`n o^ng Ky` thi` chi? la` nha` KH.DDie^?m na`y ne^'u
la`m to^'t thi` se~ cha.y ddu*o*.c to^.i "co^' y'" cho o^ng Ky`,vi` theo
ba`i ba'o thi` la` o^ng Ky` kho^ng nha^.n ddu*o*.c va(n ba?n hu*o*'ng
da^~n cu. the^? na`o cu?a UBND ti?nh ca? (o*? dda^y cu~ng pha?i ddie^`u
tra ky~ qua tha^n nha^n cu?a o^ng Ky` la` lie^.u o^ng co' bi. ma('c
tha`nh to^i. ho^'i lo^. kho^ng ).Cu~ng ca^`n lu*u y' la` o*? VN
thu*o*`ng hay "che^'t" vi` "a'n ddie^?m",ba^y gio*` VN ddang dda'nh
ra^'t na(.ng to^.i "co^' y' la`m tra'i quy ddi.nh ve^` qua?n ly' kinh
te^'",co' the^? ho. ddang ca^`n mo^.t va`i a'n ddie^?m tha^.t na(.ng
dde^? chu*'ng to? co^ng minh cu?a xa~ho^.i,ddie^`u na`y ca'c ba'c fan
cu?a o^ng Ky` ne^n he^'t su*'c lu*u y'.
Va`i do`ng phie^'m loa.n cu`ng ca'c ba'c tha^`y ca~i cho o^ng Ky`
Tha^n me^'n 
DDoa`n Kim Hoa

Hoang Khoa Quyen wrote:
> 
> Tu+` nha` nghiªn cu+'u tro+? tha`nh bi. ca'o
> 
> ( Bao' Ngu+o+`i lao ddo^.ng ra nga`y Thu+' Tu+ 25-8-99 )
> 
> Nga`y 23/8/1999, sau 18 tha'ng ta.m giam, TAND Tha`nh pho^' DDa` Na(~ng dda~
> ddu+a vu. a'n Tra^`n Phu+o+ng Ky` (tu+'c Tra^`n Ky` Phu+o+ng) ra xe't xu+?.
> Pho`ng xu+? a'n ddo^ng nghe.t ngu+o+`i ma` ngoa`i tha^n nha^n bi. ca'o,
> ha^`u he^'t nhu+~ng ngu+o+`i tham du+. la` gio+'i tri' thu+'c va` va(n
> nghe^. si~. Bo+?i bi. ca'o la` mo^.t nghie^n cu+'u Cha(mpa no^?i tie^'ng.
> 
> DDe^` ta`i nghie^n cu+'u vo+'i 138.185 USD.
> 
> Theo ca'o tra.ng, khoa?ng va`o giu+~a na(m 1993, o^ng Makita - chu? ti.ch
> to^? chu+'c Toyota Foundation (mo^.t to^? chu+'c phi chi'nh phu? cu?a
> Nha^.t( co' cuo^.c la`m vie^.c vo+'i UBND ti?nh Qua?ng Nam - DDa` Na(~ng
> cu~). Buo^?i la`m vie^.c na`y co' o^ng Nguye^~n DDi`nh An, Pho' chu? ti.ch
> UBND ti?nh, hie^.n nay la` Chu? ti.ch Uy? ban MTTQ Vie^.t Nam tha`nh pho^'
> DDa` Na(~ng, o^ng Nguye^~n Va(n Cu+. - ca'n bo^. Vu. Ho+.p ta'c quo^'c te^'
> thuo^.c Trung ta^m Khoa ho.c Xa~ ho^.i va` Nha^n va(n quo^'c gia va` o^ng
> Tra^`n Phu+o+ng Ky` - ba?o ta`ng vie^n Ba?o ta`ng DDa` Na(~ng. Phi'a Toyota
> Foundaition dda~ ddo^`ng y' ta`i tro+. ve^` ta`i chi'nh cho mo^.t so^' dde^`
> ta`i nghie^n cu+'u cu?a Vie^.t Nam ve^` li.ch su+?, va(n hoa' va` da^n
> to^.c. Sau ddo', So+? VHTT Qua?ng Nam - DDa` Na(~ng (cu~) dda~ pho^? bie^'n
> la.i cho ca'n bo^. trong nga`nh va(n hoa' tinh tha^`n cu?a phi'a Toyota
> Foundation va` dde^` nghi. ca'n bo^. trong nga`nh nghie^n cu+'u xa^y du+.ng
> dde^` ta`i go+?i cho So+? va` Uy? ban duye^.t dde^? tri`nh phi'a Toyota
> Foundation xin ta`i tro+. ve^` ta`i chi'nh. Mo^.t trong ba dde^` ta`i
> ddu+o+.c Toyota Foundation cho.n lu'c ba^'y gio+` co' dde^` ta`i cu?a Tra^`n
> Phu+o+ng Ky`: "Nghie^n cu+'u nghe^. thua^.t va` va(n minh vu+o+ng quo^'c
> Cha(mpa co^? dda.i" vo+'i no^.i dung so^' ddo trong lo`ng tha'p, ngoa`i xung
> quanh tha'p, chu.p a?nh, la^.p ba?ng ve~ ky~ thua^.t ca'c tha'p Cha`m ta.i
> mie^`n Trung. Theo du+. toa'n, kinh phi' thu+.c hie^.n dde^` ta`i na`y le^n
> dde^'n 138.185 USD trong tho+`i gian 3 na(m.
> 
> Co^' y' la`m tra'i ?
> 
> Tra^`n Phu+o+ng Ky` bi. co+ quan ddie^`u tra kho+?i to^' to^.i "Co^' y' la`m
> tra'i quy ddi.nh cu?a Nha` nu+o+'c ve^` qua?n ly' kinh te^' ga^y ha^.u qua?
> nghie^m tro.ng: vi` theo VKS, sau khi phi'a Toyota Foundation ddo^`ng y'
> ta`i tro+. cho dde^` ta`i cu?a Tra^`n Phu+o+ng Ky`, Tra^`n Phu+o+ng Ky` dda~
> la^.p ta`i khoa?n rie^ng ta.i Nga^n ha`ng Ngoa.i thu+o+ng DDa` Na(~ng dde^?
> to^? chu+'c na`y chuye^?n tie^`n va`o Vie^.t Nam tra'nh su+. qua?n ly' cu?a
> Nha` nu+o+'c, tra'i vo+'i Quye^'t ddi.nh 80 Chu'ng to^i nga`y 28/3/1991 cu?a
> Chu? ti.ch HDDBT (nay la` Thu' tu+o+'ng Chi'nh phu?). So^' tie^`n cu?a
> Toyota Foundation chuye^?n va`o cho Tra^`n Phu+o+ng Ky` thu+.c hie^.n dde^`
> ta`i de^'n khi bi. co+ quan ddie^`u tra kho+?i to^' to^?ng co^.ng la` 89.944
> USD. So^' tie^`n tre^n bi. ca'o khai dda~ su+? du.ng va`o ca'c vie^.c ddo
> dda.c, mua va^.t tu+, phim slide, la^.p ba?n ve~ ky~ thua^.t, mua va(n
> pho`ng pha^?m, chi phi' a(n o+? ddi la.i cho chuye^n gia Nha^.t... Mo^.t
> so^' khoa?n dda~ ddu+o+.c co+ quan ddie^`u tra xa'c minh la` ddu'ng.Vie^.c
> to^? chu+'c Toyota Foundation ta`i tro+. cho dde^` ta`i cu?a Tra^`n Phu+o+ng
> Ky` va` bi. ca'o sau ddo' dda~ mo+? ta`i khoa?n rie^ng, la~nh dda.o ba?o
> ta`ng va` So+? VHTT Qua?ng Nam - DDa` Na(~ng co' bie^'t. O^ng Ho^` Ha?i Ho.c
> - Gia'm ddo^'c So+? VHTT Tha`nh pho^' DDa` Na(~ng, nguye^n gia'm ddo^'c Ba?o
> ta`ng Qua?ng Nam - DDa` Na(~ng ddu+o+.c mo+`i dde^'n phie^n toa` vo+'i tu+
> ca'ch la` ngu+o+`i co' lie^n quan. O^ng Nguye^~n DDi`nh An va('ng ma(.t.
> Ta.i phie^n toa`, o^ng Ho^` Ha?i Ho.c cho bie^'t khi Toyota Foundation xe't
> duye^.t dde^` ta`i cu?a Tra^`n Phu+o+ng Ky` hoa`n toa`n kho^ng tho^ng ba'o
> cho So+? VHTT hoa(.c ba?o ta`ng bie^'t. O^ng Ho^` Ha?i Ho.c cu~ng kha(?ng
> ddi.nh: "Kho^ng co' ba(`ng chu+'ng na`o no'i tie^`n ddo' chuye^?n cho ba?o
> ta`ng, ne^n kho^ng co' co+ so+? buo^.c Tra^`n Phu+o+ng Ky` pha?i no^.p la.i
> cho ba?o ta`ng!". O^ng Ho^` Ha?i Ho.c no'i: "To^i ra^'t dda'ng tie^'c la`
> dde^` ta`i cu?a o^ng Ky` co`n do+? dang, ne^'u xong ro^`i thi` xem cha^'t
> lu+o+.ng dde^` ta`i nhu+ the^' na`o, co' xu+'ng dda'ng ddo^`ng tie^`n ba't
> ga.o hay kho^ng mo+'i bie^'t vie^.c qua?n ly'". Theo o^ng Ho.c, khi thu+.c
> hie^.n dde^` ta`i cu?a ba?n tha^n o^ng, o^ng dda~ ca^?n tha^.n la^.p phie^'u
> thu chi ro~ ra`ng, nhu+ng khi ke^'t thu'c dde^` ta`i, phi'a Toyota
> Foundation kho^ng ye^u ca^`u o^ng gia?i tri`nh ve^` ta`i chi'nh, "ho. chi?
> xem cha^'t lu+o+.ng dde^` ta`i".Ba`o chu+~a cho bi. ca'o Tra^`n Phu+o+ng
> Ky`, lua^.t su+ Nguye^~n DDi`nh Phu`ng ho?i bi. ca'o: "Sau khi nha^.n
> ddu+o+.c tie^`n ta`i tro+. cu?a Toyota Foundation, co' va(n ba?n na`o cu?a
> UBND ti?nh, So+? VHTT hay ba?o ta`ng hu+o+'ng da^~n bi. ca'o la`m thu? tu.c
> nha^.n tie^`n kho^ng ?" Tra? lo+`i: "Da. kho^ng co'!".Ngoa`i to^.i danh
> "Co^' y' la`m tra'i...", Tra^`n Phu+o+ng Ky` co`n bi. truy to^' ve^` to^.i
> "Vi pha.m ca'c quy ddi.nh ve^` ba?o ve^. va` su+? du.ng di ti'ch li.ch su+?,
> va(n hoa', ga^y ha^.u qua? nghie^m tro.ng". Theo ca'o tra.ng, dda^`u na(m
> 1993, Tra^`n Phu+o+ng Ky` va`o Tam Xua^n (Nu'i Tha`nh) mua 20 tu+o+.ng Cha`m
> co' nie^n dda.i tu+` the^' ky? X cu?a mo^.t so^' ngu+o+`i dda`o ddu+o+.c
> trong khu tha'p Khu+o+ng My~ va` tha'p La.ng vo+'i gia' 26,8 trie^.u
> ddo^`ng. So^' tu+o+.ng na`y theo VKS, Tra^`n Phu+o+ng Ky` khai mua vo+'i
> mu.c ddi'ch nghie^n cu+'u. Co+ quan ddie^`u tra dda~ thu giu+~ ddu+o+.c
> 17/20 tu+o+.ng no'i tre^n, 3 tu+o+.ng co`n la.i bi. tha^'t la.c.
> 
> 10 na(m 6 tha'ng tu`.
> 
> TAND Tha`nh pho^' DDa` Na(~ng dda~ tuye^n pha.t bi. ca'o Tra^`n Phu+o+ng Ky`
> 6 tha'ng tu` giam ve^` to^.i "Vi pha.m ca'c quy ddi.nh ve^` ba?o ve^. va`
> su+? du.ng di ti'ch li.ch su+?, va(n hoa', ga^y ha^.u qua? nghie^m tro.ng",
> 10 na(m tu` giam ve^` to^.i "Co^' y' la`m tra'i quy ddi.nh cu?a Nha` nu+o+'c
> ve^` qua?n ly' kinh te^', ga^y ha^.u qua? nghie^m tro.ng". To^?ng co^.ng
> hi`nh pha.t 10 na(m 6 tha'ng tu` giam. Ngoa`i ra, bi. ca'o co`n pha?i dde^`n
> bu` khoa?n tie^`n tre^n 500 trie^.u ddo^`ng bi. thie^.t ha.i!.DDu+o+.c no'i
> lo+`i cuo^'i cu`ng tru+o+'c khi tuye^n a'n, bi. ca'o Tra^`n Phu+o+ng Ky`
> dda~ no'i: "Sau o^ng Parmentier ngu+o+`i Pha'p, to^i la` ngu+o+`i Vie^.t Nam
> dda^`u tie^n ddo dda.c be^n trong ca'c tha'p Cha`m ta.i mie^`n Trung. Nho+`
> nhu+~ng ba?n ve~ cu?a to^i, quo^'c te^' bie^'t dde^'n My~ So+n ho+n. Vie^.c
> to^i nha^.n dde^` ta`i cu?a Toyota Foundation la` vi` mu.c ddi'ch chung, vi`
> su+. nghie^.p ba?o to^`n di sa?n va(n hoa' da^n to^.c no'i chung, di sa?n
> kie^'n tu'c va(n hoa' Cha(m mie^`n Trung no'i rie^ng. Xin toa` khoan ho^`ng
> dde^? to^i so+'m tro+? ve^` tie^'p tu.c su+. nghie^.p nghie^n cu+'u "
> 
> Nh'o'm pho'ng vie^n mie^`n Trung
> 
> ______________________________________________________
> Get Your Private, Free Email at http://www.hotmail.com