If you've read the books, then you know why I gave it a 2. So after reading the books I heard there was going to be a movie. I was excited, more excited than I should have been... Now normally, I don't give bad reviews on book-to-movie films, but this was pretty awful. First off, cast choice. The characters were not portrayed at all as I pictured them while reading the books. And seriously, would it kill them to have just a little emotion? Everything's all "Oh no... The lights are gonna go out, how terrible." Compared to the book where its like "We gotta do something about this lighting situation." Get what I'm saying? Either way, I honestly understand why they haven't continued the movie series for this. Anyway, that's my review. Thanks for considering my opinion by reading this. :-)

I can't even begin to summarize how much I loath this movie in a short amou I HATE this movie more than the Percy Jackson movies or even The Last Airbender! In the trailer they give away the plot twist at the end of the book in the first few seconds! None of the actors have personality and the movie decides to completely ruin any sort of relation to the plot by adding things like giant mole-monsters and secret telephone messages!!! Oh, and by the way, the job of one of the main characters is messenger, someone who runs across the city to deliver messages to people by voice. They never had phones! The only thing that is remotely good about the movie, the city itself, is still hugely flawed! Why is everyone wearing strange clothing? Why is the lighting not match the gritty, electrical feel of the city, and instead looks like broad daylight? Why is everything cramped? (Yeah I know, that whole "underground" thing, but in the book, you are not suppose to know it's underground, so it is described as a large, wide open city. This ruins the whole effect! I have written a longer rant on this horrible film's youtube page. But to attempt to summarize. THIS IS THE WORST MOVIE I HAVE EVER SEEN!

Not bad Its a commen fact that books will always be better then movies I liked it because it was cool to see what was going on in the book

Great concept People need to STOP TRYING TO COMPARE BOOKS WITH THE MOVIES ! You CANNOT cram a 15 hour book reading into a 2 hour movie. Get over it and enjoy the MOVIE on it's own merit. Good premise, good plot, very good actors and the emergence of an excellent actress in Saorise.

Thiss is a hart stoping thrilling move it is the best ever!!!!!!! I love love love love love it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I love this movie This movie was amazing when I first saw it. Now when I watch city of ember it gets better and better. Also for those who hate it.... Come on now the person who made the book made the movie.

Butt So weird but cool

Ehh. Book was better. The book was so much better. The book was written for teens but this movie was a bit childish. I recommend reading the book before seeing this movie.

Wonderful movie. This is a great lesson in the need for learning about our history. Sometimes we leave things, that are greatly important, too secret for our own good. It also teaches us to help each other. Wonderful graphics!

ITS AMAZING I have seen this movie and its AMAZING but the only thing is that its WAY diffrent from the movie

City of ember It is a good movie. Its a good movie so stop complaining about it. No one wants to hear you complain about stuff

Great This movie is awesome, just a little inaccurate from the book. Can't wait until the people of sparks comes out!

I LOVE IT THIS IS THE BESTEST MOVIE I HAVE EVER SEEN I MY WHOLE LIFE TIME I LOVE IT SO MUCH

I love it I read the book first and it was phenomenal Great movie

This is a good movie, stop comparing it to the books. I think they should have made the people of Sparks movie, and the rest of the Ember series. Those of you who don't like this movie, don't complain, I don't want to hear it.

Good Really good movie loved it.

I LOVE IT! Becuase I like the book I thought it could be better but I still love it!

Lg optimus G pro Excellent movie, I would recommend this to anybody.

Great

Love it You have to see it!!!!!!!!!!!!!