Re: [cult] Village

[Hong Lam Vu <vuh000@goofy.zdv.Uni-Mainz.de>]

Hi ba'c Ian, Aiviet and all the village,

Ba'c ho.c nga`nh gi` va^.y, k0 khe'o mi`nh la` ddo^`ng nghie^.p ga^`n
cu~ng ne^n. Tui cu~ng da^n social scientist dda^y.
> 
> - VMLX cua? ta co' tru*o*'c hay sau tho*i` ky` Ha'n thuo^.c#?

Truo+'c. VMLX dduo+.c coi la` 1 dda(.c thu` cu?a pre-Chinese, pre-
Indian South East Asian civilization.

Tui co' hypothesis sau: trong khi kha'i nie^.m va(n minh (civilization) 
o+? c'c no+i kha'c tre^n the^' gio+'i ga('n vo+'i tha`nh thi., thi` o+?
DNA no' ga('n vo+'i xo'm la`ng. Cho dde^'n nay hi`nh nhu+ kha?o co^?
ho.c va^~n chu+a ti`m duo+.c da^'u ti'ch tha`nh thi. co^? cu?a va(n minh
Ddo^ng So+n, tu+'c va(n minh DNA truo+'c Ha'n va` truo+'c A^'n. Va^.y thi`
ne^n cha(ng ddu+`ng hoa`i co^ng ddi ti`m 1 Jericho o+? VN ma` ne^n coi nh~
la`ng lo+'n do'ng vai tro` cu?a nh~ tha`nh thi. trong VM DNA. Cu~ng chi'nh
vi` da(.c ddie^?m na`y ma` 1 loa.t ca'i nhi`n ve^` civilisation quen du`ng
cho truo+`ng ho+.p Trung Ddo^ng, TQ, etc ne^n dduo+.c xe't la.i cho phu`
ho+.p vo+'i DNA. Dda(.t va^'n dde^` nhu+ the^' se~ gia?i thi'ch dduo+.c 1
loa.t hie^.n tuo+.ng cu?a xh DNA. Toa`n bo^. ca^'u tru'c xh DNA da(.t
tre^n 1 co+ ta^`ng (substrat) ma` mo^ hi`nh ca(n ba?n cu?a no' la` mo^
hi`nh xo'm la`ng. Nuo+'c cu~ng nhu+ 1 sie^u la`ng. Ba?n tha^n VNSA ta
cu~ng nhu+ 1 ca'i la`ng.

> - VMLX co' nhu*ng~ u*u khuye^t' ddie^m? nao`#?

Ba'c k0 ddu+a ra he^. quy chie^'u. U+u , khuye^'t ddie^?m pha?i dduo+.c
chie^'u va`o 1 he^. chua^?n nha^'t di.nh, dduo+.c gio+'i ha.n bo+?i tho+`i
va` kho^ng gian.

Vi' du. che^' ddo^. dda the^ co' the^? co' u+u ddie^?m trong 1 xh ma`
dda`n o^ng bi. che^'t ra^'t nhie^`u do dda'nh gia(.c, kie^'m so^'ng, etc,
nhu+ng la.i la` co' khuye^'t ddie^?m trong tho+`i dda.i ky~ nghe^. nhu+
hie^.n nay.

> - VMLX co`n kho^ng, hay dda~ hoa<.c ddang bie^'n da.ng#?
> 

Co`n. No' va^~n ddo'ng vai tro` co+ ta^`ng cho toa`n bo^. ne^`n VH VN
hie^.n dda.i, tre^n do' phu? 1 lo+'p va(n minh Ha'n ho'a da`y co^.p ma`
mo?ng be^n tre^n la` va(n minh Ta^y phuo+ng.

Tui k0 thi'ch vu+'t bo? ha(?n VMLX dde^? thay ba(`ng ca'c ye^'u to^'
thua^`n Ta^y phuo+ng (i.e. hie^.n dda.i), ma` co' le~ cu~ng k0 la`m
dduo+.c (da^n DNA ngoan co^' la('m, ma^'y anh Muslims be^n Malaysia,
Indonesia kha'c ha(?n ma^'y anh Arabs, anh Nho VN cu~ng kha'c ha(?n
anh Nho Ta`u, Nha^.t, Ha`n).

Tuy nhie^n dda(.t va^'n dde^` whether modernisation = Westernization la` 1
ca'ch dda(.t va^'n dde^` misleading. Theo fuzzy logic, co' ho+i ta^y
phuo+ng ho'a, kha' TPH, ra^'t TPH, cu+.c ky` TPH, etc.. Va^'n dde^` co'
le~ la` TPH ca'i gi`, va` dde^'n dda^u, chu+' k0 pha?i la` to westernize
or not to westernize. BTW ca'ch dda(.t va^'n dde^` kie^?u Hamlet la` 1
da(.c sa('c Ta^y phuo+ng ma` gio+'i elite Ddo^ng phuo+ng bi. tie^m nhie^~m
ma` k0 bie^'t. Dde^` nghi. Dr Mahathir Mohammad va` Mr Lee Kuan Yew ha~y
tro+? ve^` "A' Ddo^ng ti'nh" ngay o+? ca'ch dda(.t va^'n dde^`.

Cheers,
Hong Lam