Re: Ba`i Review cu?a TS Nguyen Xuan Tuyen

[Tran Minh Tien <tran@idefix.mpipks-dresden.mpg.de>]

Cha`o ca'c  ba'c,

> > Be^n Toa'n co' ve?  hay co' "chuye^.n" khi ai ddo' ddu+o+.c
> > le^n chu+'c. Ho^`i o^ng DDa`o Tro.ng Thi le^n la`m Hie^.u
> > tru+o+?ng  hi`nh nhu+ cu~ng co' xi` xa`o gi` ddo' ve^` ba`i 
> > review quye^?n sa'ch gi` ddo'\. 
> > 
> 
> Chuye^.n co' "quan he^." gi\ giu+~a 3 nha^n va^.t kho^ng thi\ to^i kho^ng
> bie^'t,
> nhu+ng kho^ng the^? so sa'nh vie^.c na\y vo+'i chuye^.n cu?a o^ng Thi, va\
> cu~ng kho^ng the^? vi\ the^' ma\ ke^'t lua^.n la\ gio+'i toa'n "la('m
> chuye^.n".


A^'y ba'c Du~ng o+i, to^i chi? nghe ho+i no^`i cho~ tho^i\. Va` to^i
vie^'t la` "hay co' "chuye^.n"", chu+' kho^ng pha?i la` "la('m chuye^.n"
dda^u\. To^i la` ke? "ngoa.i dda.o" dda^u da'm vo+ ca'c ba'c be^n Toa'n
tha`nh 1 na('m dda^u\. To^i chi? so sa'nh o+? cho^~ khi o^ng Thi ra
tranh Hie^.u tru+o+?ng thi` ngu+o+`i ta xi` xa`o sa'ch cu?a o^ng, va`
tru+o+`ng ho+.p na`y o^ng Tuye^'n ra la`m Hie^.u tru+o+?ng thi` cu~ng 
bi. xi` xa`o ve^` lua^.n va(n. Ne^'u ca'c o^ng a^'y kho^ng la`m Hie^.u 
tru+o+?ng thi` lie^.u co' xi` xa`o kho^ng ?

Y' kie^'n rie^ng cu?a to^i ve^` tru+o+`ng ho+.p o^ng Tuye^'n la` the^'
na`y: ba`i review cu?a o^ng Hu+ng nhi`n chung la` to^'t, nhu+ng chi? 
review ve^` 1 ba`i ba'o, kho^ng pha?i lua^.n va(n. Nhu+ng to^i kho^ng 
ca?m tha^'y ha`i lo`ng ve^` ba`i review cu?a o^ng Hu+ng. Ne^'u o^ng
Hu+ng tha^'y ba`i o^ng Tuye^'n sai hay a(n ca('p sao kho^ng vie^'t
comment dde^? o^ng Tuye^'n co' kha? na(ng tra? lo+`i\. Phe^ pha'n
ba(`ng review khie^'n ta'c gia? dda^u co' co+ ho^.i pha?n bie^.n la.i\.
To^i ddo^`ng y' vo+'i anh A'i Vie^.t la` co' i't nha^'t co' 1 referee
dda~ ddo^`ng y' va` 1 editor dda~ cha^'p nha^.n cho dda(ng ba`i cu?a
o^ng Tuye^'n. Co`n ne^'u no'i co' the^? co' "cha^m chu+o+'c" trong
qua' tri`nh edition, the^' thi` sao kho^ng nghi~ co' the^?  co' gi`
ddo' trong qua' tri`nh review ? Ngoa`i ra co`n pha?i xem ba`i cu?a
o^ng Huy`nh Mu`i dda(ng co' ddu+o+.c nhie^`u ngu+o+`i bie^'t kho^ng ?
O^ng Tuye^'n co' bie^'t ba`i o^ng Hu`ynh Mu`i kho^ng ?
Thie^'u gi` tru+o+`ng ho+.p la`m tru`ng nhau vi` thie^'u communication.

Tuy nhie^n vie^.c o^ng Tuye^'n la`m ma^'t lua^.n va(n khie^'n
to^i ra^'t nghi ngo+` ve^` lua^.n va(n cu?a o^ng a^'y\. Du`
sao cha(ng nu+~a trung thu+.c la` ddie^`u to^'i quan tro.ng 
nha^'t la` khi la`m tha^`y gia'o\.

Cheers,

Tran Minh Tien