Physicists' viewpoint Re: Sa('c dde.p trong ma('t ai?

[Aiviet Nguyen <aiviet@cat.syr.edu>]

Hello Anh Hai and Lam,
   
    According to the gentleman generation's physicists the beauty is the
simplicity:
   P.Dirac found the positron by the simplicity of his equation.

   However, the generation of the black sheaf physicists found that the 
violation of symmetry ( simplicity) is the real beauty. Lee and Yang
won the Nobel price because of the discory of parity violation ( the 
left-right symmetry).

   I agree with Anh Lam about the concept of beauty is related to evolution.
However, let me kill the Ph.D topic by giving a trivial theory:
   First step, symmetry gives people a concept. In the case of the beauty, 
that is the concept of beauty. At this step, people learn that the beauty 
is there and become excited for its prospect.
   Second step, a small violation let people go from the concept to an 
instance. By the violation people and perceive the realistic thing. In 
our case, we start to pick up a beauty and build our ideal on it.
   Third step, the violation becomes large, new concepts and new symmetries
should be used. The old ideal is totally broken.
   Fourth step, we get used with the new beauty and try to violate it by 
a small amount.
   By the way, all these were in my M.Sc Thesis 20 years ago. No Ph.D
was awarded, but my supervisor, after reading it, said that it was no need
for him to read further.

   Also think about the accords 7 as violation of the regular accords.
The regular accords are beautiful, but the 7 ones like spices to break 
the monoton rhythm.

Cheers
Aiviet