RE: Tra^`n Ma.nh Ha?o

[Tuan Pham <Tuan.Pham@unsw.edu.au>]

Hi ca'c ba'c

Ca'c Ba'c Aiviet, Ho Tu Bao etc. ba?o ra(`ng kho^ng bie^'t nhie^`u
ve^` cung ca'ch phe^ bi`nh cu?a TMHa?o nhu+ng du+o+`ng nhu+ 
cho ra(`ng o^ng ta kho^ng pha?i la` "quan" hay "bo^`i bu't".
Su+. thu+.c thi` to^i cu~ng kho^ng bie^'t gi` ve^` o^ng na`y,
do ddo' low opinion cu?a to^i hoa`n toa`n do ba`i phe^ bi`nh CHCC .
(Co' the^? kho^ng pha?i la` tri`nh ddo^. tha^.t cu?a o^ng ta ma`
la` tri`nh ddo^. cu?a ca'i persona ma` o^ng muo^'n ddo'ng, nhu+ng 
ca'i ddo' irrelevant.) Ma^'y truye^.n, tho+ nga`y xu+a cu?a TMH ma` 
ca'c ba'c mo+'i tri'ch thi` la`m cho to^i co' ca?m ti`nh. 

[
Nhu+ to^i dda~ no'i, ddo.c 1 ba`i phe^ bi`nh mi`nh de^~ da`ng nha^.n 
ra tri`nh ddo^. du` chu+a ddo.c ta'c pha^?m ma` ho. phe^ bi`nh. 
Ca'c ba'c muo^'n kie^?m chu+'ng thi` cu+' vie^.c do+? ma^'y 
to+` ba'o ha?i ngoa.i ra ddo.c thu+? 1 va`i ba`i, ngu+o+`i na`o 
tri`nh ddo^. tha^'p la` tha^'y lo^. ra lie^`n tu+` nh~ la^.p lua^.n 
non no+'t va` gio.ng ddie^.u a^'u tri~, du` la` ho. ngu.y trang 
du+o+'i lo^'t "phe^ bi`nh va(n ho.c". Cha(?ng ha.n, ddo.c ba`i 
"nghie^n ki'u chu+~ Vie^.t" du+o+'i dda^y ca'c ba'c co' tha^'y 
ngay tri`nh ddo^. ng` vie^'t kho^ng:

     ...Cha('c-cha('n
     la` ca'c ddo^`-dde^. Ma'c Le^ lo^-can ra^'t muo^'n noi gu+o+ng Ho^`
     Chi' Minh khi la~o gia` na`y tu+. tay na('n-no't vie^'t te^n tre^n
     bi`a cho mo^.t ta^.p sa'ch la` "DDu+o+`ng Ka'ch-Me^.nh" ma` dda?ng
     co^.ng-sa?n Vie^.t-Nam xem la` mo^.t kie^.t-ta'c trong "toa`n-thu+"
     cu?a ho. Ho^`, ke? cu~ng la` ta'c-gia? cu?a nhu+~ng tu+`-ngu+~
     qua'i-dda?n kie^?u "ddie^.u ho` vi~ da(.m", v.v... ma` ro^'t cuo^.c
     cu~ng cha(?ng co' "ddo^`ng-chi'" na`o ba('t chu+o+'c du`ng theo.

(tri'ch tu+` vhnt no.466 - sorry ba'c Du~ng Fl! :-)
]

Search la.i vnsa thi` tha^'y la` chi'nh mi`nh dda~ forward 1 
ddoa.n tu+` ba'o Vie^.t no'i ve^` TMH ma` kho^ng nho+'! 
Sau dda^y la` ddoa.n nha` va(n Hoa`ng Linh (kho^ng pha?i 
HL ddi tu`, va` cu~ng kho^ng pha?i ba'c HL mo.t sa'ch o+? 
Hungary), ke^? la.i vu. Tra^`n Ma.nh Ha?o vie^'t ba'o Co^ng an dde^? 
hua` theo chi'nh quye^`n oa'nh ddo^`ng nghie^.p DDo^~ Minh Tua^'n 
ho^`i cuo^'i 1998.

Cheers
Tuan Pham

> 
> Ba`i "Nha^.n die^.n va(n ho.c ha?i ngoa.i" cu?a ta'c gia? Hoa`ng 
> Hua^n, mt si~ quan cu?a ba'o Qua^n DDi Nha^n Da^n in tre^n phu. 
> tru+o+ng Va(n Nghe^. Qua^n DDi so^' ra nga`y 25.9.1998 phe^ 
> pha'n tha'i dd dde^` cao va(n chu+o+ng ha?i ngoa.i cu?a DDo^~ Minh 
> Tua^'n. Vo+'i tu+ ca'ch mt chuye^n gia nhie^`u na(m nghie^n cu+'u 
> li~nh vu+.c na`y va` dda~ vie^'t nhie^`u ba`i phe^ pha'n ca'c hoa.t
ddng 
> va(n hoa' va(n chu+o+ng ha?i ngoa.i, o^ng gia`nh qua' nu+?a ba`i ba'o 
> va.ch ra ba?n cha^'t cho^'ng cng cu?a ne^`n va(n chu+o+ng na`y 
> qua nhu+~ng tu+ lie^.u qua' cu~, vo+'i mt ca'ch nhi`n qua' thie^n 
> kie^'n, ddo+n gia?n mt chie^`u cu?a tho+`i chie^'n tranh la.nh. Sau 
> ddo' o^ng ta^.p trung phe^ pha'n tha'i dd chi'nh tri. cu?a DDo^~ Minh 
> Tua^'n trong ba`i "Va(n ho.c ha?i ngoa.i nhi`n tu+` trong nu+o+'c" 
> (Vie^.t so^' 2), le^n a'n ca'i a?o vo.ng pha't ha`nh ca'c ta.p chi'
va(n 
> chu+o+ng ha?i ngoa.i trong nu+o+'c cu?a anh, ro^`i ke^'t lua^.n co' 
> ti'nh cha^'t ra(n dde ra(`ng: "Ne^'u la`m to^?n ha.i to+'i quye^`n
lo+.i 
> cu?a da^n tc thi` se~ bi. li.ch su+? pha'n xe't mt ca'ch co^ng ba(`ng
> va` 
> so`ng pha(?ng." Ba`i cu?a Hoa`ng Hua^n dda~ cha^m ngo`i cho mt 
> chie^'n di.ch ta^'n co^ng do^`n da^.p va`o DDo^~ Minh Tua^'n tu+` 
> nhie^`u phi'a, cu~ng hu+`ng hu+.c khi' the^' gio^'ng nhu+ ddo+.t
ta^'n 
> co^ng va`o ba`i "Linh ho^`n va(n hoa' trong tha^n xa'c thi ca" va` 
> cuo^'n sa'ch Nga`y va(n ho.c le^n ngo^i cu?a anh na(m 1997. Co' 
> ddie^`u, ddo+.t ta^'n co^ng na`y chi? die^~n ra tre^n ca'c ba`i ba'o
> cu?a 
> Qua^n ddi va` Co^ng an vo+'i nhu+~ng quy ke^'t chi'nh tri. kha' 
> na(.ng ne^`. Ba`i cu?a Tra^`n Ma.nh Ha?o ky' bu't danh DDa(.ng Tha`nh 
> Nam in tre^n dda(.c san ba'o Co^ng an tha`nh pho^' Ho^` Chi' Minh 
> so^' ra nga`y 5 tha'ng 11 na(m 1998 dda~ quy ke^'t DDo^~ Minh 
> Tua^'n tie^'p tay cho phong tra`o chuye^?n lu+?a ve^` que^ hu+o+ng 
> nha(`m la^.t ddo^? che^' dd cng sa?n, co' quan he^. tie^'p lu+?a
vo+'i 
> dda`i RFI, "mo'c no^'i" vo+'i ta.p chi' Die^~n DDa`n ta.i Praha la`
to+`
> ba'o 
> cho^'ng cng khe't tie^'ng. DDo' la` nhu+~ng suy lua^.n tu+` ca'c 
> tho^ng tin ma` DDo^~ Minh Tua^'n ddu+a ra trong ba`i in tre^n Vie^.t 
> so^' 2. Ta'c gia? na`y co`n suy lua^.n ke? ky' bu't hie^.u Nguye^~n 
> Hu+ng Quo^'c dda~ bc l y' ddo^` ke'o qua^n ve^` gia?i pho'ng dda^'t 
> nu+o+'c dde^? "hu+ng quo^'c" (?!).
> ...