Re: Ngu.y va` Hu`ng bie^.n Re: [CUL]Adam vs. Eva/Feminism/Dda.o Nha^'t vo+. nhi` gio+`i

[Hong Lam Vu <vuh000@goofy.zdv.Uni-Mainz.de>]

Hi ba'c Vie^.t,

> Ngu.y bie^.n theo y' to^i la` ddi.nh tru+o+'c ke^'t qua? ro^`i mo+'i ly' 
> lua^.n. Anh co' y' ddi.nh la^'y lo`ng chi. em phu. nu+~ ne^n theo ca'i 
> chu? thuye^'t ti`nh, hay la` thua^.n vo+. cho^`ng, sau ddo' thi` la^.p 
> lua^.n the^' na`o ma` cha? ddu+o+.c.
>   To^i thi` cho ra(`ng me^.nh dde^` na`o cu~ng co' the^? chu+'ng minh 
> ddu+o+.c he^'t ba(`ng ly' lua^.n. Ca'i xua^'t pha't ddie^?m co' khi na(`m
> sa^u trong mo^.t ca'ch su+? du.ng thua^.t ngu+~ ma` tho^i.
> 

Hay la('m. I agree with you. Nhu+ng ne^'u va^.y thi` tranh ca~i co' y'
nghi~a gi` khi tranh ca~i la` du`ng ly' lua^.n dde^? "co. sa't" quan
ddie^?m. Trong khi mo.i va^'n de^` dde6`u co' the^/ chu+'ng minh ba(`ng
ly' lua^.n?

Theo tui hie^?u, y' ba'c Vie^.t muo^'n no'i dde^'n ca'c me^.nh dde^`
analytic, i.e without empiry. Vo+'i ca'c me^.nh dde^` analytic thi` kho^ng
co' chuye^.n ddu'ng hay sai, chi? ca^`n logic, ma` logic thi` ddu? loa.i.

Tha`nh ra ddo^i khi co' hai ke^'t lua^.n khi formulated thi` contending
nhu+ng thu+.c ra dde^`u "ddu'ng" vi` chu'ng define their terminologies in
different way. Vi' du.:

>   Cha(?ng ha.n la` ca'i chuye^.n Nguo^`n go^'c ngu+o+`i Vie^.t ma` chu+a 
> ddi.nh nghi~a Ngu+o+`i Vie^.t la` the^' na`o va` ma(.c nhie^n cho no' co' 
> mo^.t ca'i ba?n the^? ngoa`i nhu+~ng vo? ngo^n ngu+~ va(n hoa'. To^i so+. 
> ra(`ng bo'c he^'t ca'c loa.i vo? thi` cha(?ng co' gi`. ( Positivism).
> 

Vo+'i nhu+~ng ca'ch ddi.nh nghi~a kha'c nhau ve6` "ng` Vie^.t" se~ cho nh~
ke^'t qu/a kha'c nhau ve6` nguo^`n go^'c ng` Vie^.t. Kho^ng co' ca'ch
ddi.nh nghi~a na`o "du'ng" ho+n ca'ch ddi.nh nghi~a na`o, chi? co' ca'ch
na`o ho+.p ho+n ca? vo+'i mo^.t mu.c ddi'ch (nghie^n cu+'u, lua^.n
chie^'n, cai tri., pha?n cai tri., v.v..) na`o do' tho^i.

>   Chi? ca'c nha` ba?n the^? mo+'i gio?i khoa ngu.y bie^.n.
> 

Ca^u na`y chi? ddu'ng khi ta ddi.nh nghi~a nha` ba?n the^? la` nguo+`i
gio?i khoa ngu.y bie^.n. 

Cheers,
La^m.