Re: Mien Nam Khai Phong

[ntran@acceltech.com (Ninh Tran)]

Xin co' va`i nha^.n xe't ve^` y' kie^'n cua anh Tran Minh Tie^'n:

>Nhie^.m vu. cu?a va(n ho.c su+? kho^ng pha?i dde^? ti`m ra ta'c pha^?m
>na`o dda^`u tie^n, thu+' nha^'t, thu+' hai ... ma` dde^? chi? ra su+.
>minh bie^'n cu?a va(n ho.c\. DDie^`u na`y co' nghi~a ti`m hie^?u ta'c
>pha^?m va(n ho.c theo khuynh hu+o+'ng:
...
>Kho^ng co' gia' tri. gi` ve^` va(n ho.c su+? ne^'u ai ddo' co' the^?
>chi? ra ca^u tho+ lu.c ba't co^? nha^'t, ba`i tho+` DDu+o+`ng lua^.t
>chu+~ No^m dda^`u tie^n ... Cu~ng pha?i ca^`n nho+' kha'i nie^.m "dda^`u
>tie^n", "thu+' nha^'t" ... chi? la` ca'i cu~ nha^'t ma` ta hie^.n ti`m   
tha^'y.
>DDie^`u ddo' kho^ng kha(?ng ddi.nh no' thu+.c su+. la` ca'i "dda^`u   
tie^n",
>"thu+' nha^'t". DDa^'y chi? la` mo^.t phie^'m chi?\.

DDu+'ng ve^` phu+o+ng die^n phe^ binh va(n ho.c, ta'c pha^m dda^'u tie^n   
hay thu+' hai khong quan trong.
Tuy nhien, ddu+ng ve^` phu+o+ng dien lich su+, hay khi xe't ve^` anh   
huo+ng cua? cac no^? lu.c dda^`u tie^n, nha^'t la` khi ca'c no^? lu+.c   
ddo' ga^y ra ca? mo^.t phong trao`, vi. tr'i cu?a ca'c ta'c pha^m dda^`u   
tie^n ba(`ng chu+? QN pha?i ddu+o+c  dda(.t cho ddu'ng cho^?.  Ta.i sao   
khi chu'ng ta quan ta^m de^'n ta'c pha^m dda^`u tie^n ba(`ng chu+ No^m,   
ma` la.i kho^ng nha(c nho+? dde^'n ta'c pha^m dda^`u tie^n ba(ng chu+ QN?

MNKP ddu+a va^'n dde^` la` vai tro` tie^`n phong cu?a ca'c ta'c gia? mien   
nam o+ ha^.u ba'n the^ ky? 19 dda~ kho^ng ddu+o+c dda(.t ddu'ng mu+'c,   
ca? o+ hai mien, bac va` nam. Nha^n xe't ddo', theo to^i nghi~,
pha?n an?h kha' trung thu+c xa~ ho^.i mien nam truoc 75.

>La^'y vi' du., truye^.n "Tha^`y Lasoro" (sp ?) gi` ddo' la` tie^?u   
thuye^'t cu~ nha^'t ma` hie^.n
>ay ti`m tha^'y\. Ta'c pha^?m na`y co' a?nh hu+o+?ng gi` dde^'n va(n ho'a
>a~ ho^.i va` ca'c sa'ng ta'c ddu+o+ng tho+`i hay ve^` sau kho^ng ? Ne^'u
>ho^ng thi` thu+? ho?i no' co' gia' tri. gi` ve^` va(n ho.c su+? ?

Co' hai ddie^m ca^`n pha?i no'i o+? dda^y:

1. G'ia tri. cu?a ca'c tac' pha^?m ba(`ng chu+? QN dda^u tie^n chi'nh o+?   
cho^? no' la` ca'c ta'c pha^?m dda^u tie^n. G'ia tri. cu?a no' la` gia'   
tri. tie^n phong, khai pho'ng. No' pha?n an?h ca'ch so^'ng, ca'ch no'i,   
ca'ch suy nghi~ cua xa hoi mien nam tho+i ddo'. Quan nie^m cho ra(ng gia'   
tri. cu?a mo^.t ta'c pha^m la` o+  ta^`m a?nh huo+ng xa~ ho^i cu?a no',   
theo to^i nghi~, ho+i hie^.n thu+c xa~ ho^.i. O+ dda^y chi? xin nha('c   
ra(`ng co' ca'c quan diem kha'c nu+a ve^` gia' tri.

2. An?h hu+o+ng cu?a ca'c ta'c pha^m ba(ng chu+ QN dda^u tien ra sao ddoi   
voi+ ca'c sa'ng ta'c ddu+o+ng tho+`i? Ddo' la`  ca? mo^.t lua^n a'n tien   
si. Xin cho+' vo^.i ke^'t lua^.n.