forwarded msg: Ve^` vu. GS Tuye^n, ho.c ha`m ho.c vi. o+? VN

[AnHai Doan <anhai@cs.washington.edu>]

>From a VNSA netter. Please note that if you want to post anonymously,
you are welcome to send your messages to the VNSA admins.
-----------------------------------------------------------

Hi ba'c AiViet va` ca'c ba'c,

Theo nhu y kien cua ba'c AiViet thi toi cung ro them ve cach thuc review
cua Math. Review. Cung phai noi them la mot so tap chi Abstract chi dang
to'm tat noi dung, thuong do nha xuat ban lam va khong neu ten nguoi
reviewer. Ta hieu nom na day la nghe^` cua ho., chuyen do.c roi to'm tat la.i.
Cai y cua toi noi trong message lan truoc ve qui dinh bai dang khi bao ve
nen duoc hieu cho dung nhu sau. Mot so Truong cua My, khong nhat thiet la
Ph.D students co' bai da duoc da(ng moi duoc bao ve. Khi cham luan an, Hoi
Dong biet chac chan rang tu cai luan a'n do se co (it nhat la 3 ba`i) ca'c
bai bao duoc viet ra. Ho coi day la pha^`n ba('t buoc cua mot Ph.D student
khi duoc cong nhan la Ph.D. Cho toi lam, thuong sau khi bao ve, cac ta^n
Ph.D thuong lu+u la.i tu 3 den 6 tha'ng (hoac lam luon post-doc) de viet ba`i.
Nhac lai la mot so nuoc khac thi co' bai da duoc da(ng la yeu cau bat buoc
de Ph.D student duoc phep gui luan an den Hoi Dong xem xet. Thuong qui dinh
la 2 bai. Mot so Truong nhu Paris VI yeu cau la 3, di nhien phai la ca'c
bai dang trong ca'c tap chi duoc indexed trong cac database co uy tin.
De chinh xac hon va de thong tin duoc toan dien, toi thong bao cho ca'c
ba'c cai tin toi vua nghe lo?m duoc la mot so Truong cua My cung co qui
dinh so bai phai co truoc khi bao ve. Nghe hoi rung ron, vi can bao ve ve
"Vat ly ly thuyet" chang han thi o Truong NY can 10 bai da duoc da(ng!!!.
Boi the it co ai hoan thanh luan an truoc 6 na(m.

Toi cung khong ranh ve hoc vi cua Lien Xo. Nghe ba'c AiViet noi la TS to,
vay chac TS nho? la PTS hay la Candidate. Bang quan sat thi toi thay rang,
co hai loai TS to (chac la Doctor Nayuk): La`m TS to (chac mat 4-5 nam gi
do') va lam TTS cao cap roi tha`nh TS to. Khong ro hien nay Vietnam con gui
nguoi di TTS cao cap hay khong? Khoang nhung nam cuoi 80 dau 90 toi co biet
nhieu nguoi tu Vietnam di TTS cao cap tai Nga hay Bun trong vong 1 nam roi
ve tro thanh TS to. Neu nhu ca'c ba'c noi la TS to can 20 cong trinh...thi
trong vong mot nam chac lam khong xue, boi the thuong la nhung nguoi di TTS
cao cap tap hop lai nhung cai ho da lam truoc day, phu them voi cai lam
trong nam do roi bao ve. Phai chang do la co so de nguoi ta keu ve chat
luong cua TS to trong giai doan cuoi 80 dau 90?
O dau quen day! Toi khong hieu la nguoi My hay nguoi U'c nghi gi khi thay
TS to va TS nho? Nguoi Lien Xo va nguoi Vietnam chac chang nghi tai sao la
My va Uc lai chi co Ph.D. Cho nay noi them mot chut la ba'c Z noi rang 3
Ph.D khong bang mot DSc...theo toi co le ba'c nham sang hoc ha`m! Sau Ph.D
la het khong co bang na`o nua (theo duong ho.c ha`nh), con DSc la do phong
va cai do co the hieu la tuo+'c hieu (rat cao qui'). Ben Canada co loai
DSc, U'c cung the, rieng My thi toi khong thay. Ca'c ba'c o ca'c Bang kha'c
thay the nao?
Nhan day toi muon noi them ve viec phong ho.c ha`m ben Vietnam. Neu toi nho
khong nham thi den nay nha nuoc moi phong 3 lan (goi la 3 do+.t). Dot dau
la vao cuoi nhungnam 1970 (sau khi thong nhat dat nuoc). Dot nay chi co 8
hay 9 nguoi thoi va goi la GS. Chu yeu do la nhung scientists co ten tuoi
da lau (phan da la ho.c tu thoi thuoc Phap) va giu nhung trong tra'ch trong
ca'c nganh khoa hoc cua dat nuoc. Dot thu hai khoang 45-50 nguoi (toi khong
nho chinh xac) gom ca GS va PGS. Dot thu 3 la nam kia thi phai (toi khong
biet so luong, nhung chac chan la lon hon 50). 
Mot so ba'c no'i du`a cho vui vi` khong biet, nhung ta phai hieu la da la
nha nuoc phong thi phai co qui dinh. Dai loai de duoc XE'T la PGS phai thoa
man nhungyeu cau sau day (xin loi la toi khong nho het vi khong thuoc cai
dien nay):
- Thoi gian sau khi bao ve PTS hoac TS: 5 nam.
- Co 25 (?) gio giang bai (doi voi nhung nguoi lam o cac Vien nghien cuu)
- Co 20 cong trinh (cho nay hoi kho hieu, vi du la 20 bai bao thi de hieu
hon).
- ......
O cho toi lam, tu assistant prof len associate prof can phai co' 6 bai (tat
nhien la bai loai co+~), tu associate len full can 20 bai (khong chinh xac
lam!).
Tuy tung nuoc co kha'c nhau, nhung co le ben Nhat la de dang hon ca?. Toi
nghe ban ke chuyen la sau hai nam thi assistant se duoc len associate ma
khong co bai cung duoc, vi di day thi lam gi ma co ba`i!!!
Noi them mot chut ve Nha Giao Uu tu, Nha Giao Nhan Dan, Nghe sy uu tu va
Nghe sy Nhan dan: O ca'c nganh khong phai khoa ho.c thi nha nuoc phong ca'c
Nghe Sy theo ca'c ha`m noi tren. Co le hieu nom na Uu tu' = PGS va Nhan dan
= GS.
Biet dau viet do', neu sai ca'c ba'c bo sung giup.
-----------------------------------------------------