Re: DDoa.t gu+o+m Kopa'ny (2)

[Aiviet Nguyen <aiviet2@yahoo.com>]

Hi anh Hie^.p
--- Hiep Nguyen <hduc@YAHOO.COM> wrote:
> Ha`nh ddo^.ng "cho+i kha(m" (hoax) (to^i nghi~ la`
> stunt thi` ddu'ng ho+n) cu?a o^ng khi o^ng go+?i
> mo^.t
> ba`i "gia?" cho Journal la` vi` o^ng dda~ nghie^n
> cu+'u tru+o+'c va` hie^?u lo^'i cho+i cu?a mo^.t
> so^'
> trie^'t gia? \. O^ng dda~ na(`m trong va` co'
> nghie^n
> cu+'u theo do?i kha' ky~ ca`ng tru+o+'c khi la`m
> ha`nh
> ddo^.ng ddo' \. Ddie^`u o^ng muo^'n chu+'ng to? la`
> Journal trie^'t gia? kia chi? la` cho+i chu+~ va`
> ro^~ng 

  Tui view chuye^.n na`y kha'c anh. To+` Journal kia
la` mo^.t trong nhu+~ng Journal thu+o+.ng tha(.ng o+?
My~ chu+' kho^ng pha?i chu+~ nghi~a ro^~ng. Ne^'u
chu+~ nghi~a ro^~ng thi` chuye^.n cha(?ng co' gi` hay.
Dda(ng ddu+o+.c mo^.t ba`i o+? ddo' nghe dda^u ra^'t
danh gia'. Ca'c te^n tuo^?i o^ng na`y "cho+i" cu~ng
su+`ng so? ca?. Su+'c ma^'y Sokal ddo. ddu+o+.c vo+'i
ho. ve^` ho.c thua^.t TH hay KHXH.

  To^i cho Sokal cu~ng la` mo^.t kie^?u LNBD, khi
mo^.t
he^. tho^'ng chu+~ nghi~a xa^y du+.ng tre^n mo^.t so^'
gia? thie^'t ho?ng ma` ai cu~ng cho la` hie^?n nhie^n
thi` pha?i co' scandal kie^?u Sokal.

> Quye^?n sa'ch phe^ bi`nh cu?a o^ng tri`nh
> ba`y kha' ro~ ra`ng \. Trong khoa ho.c dda~ co'
> nhie^`u tru+o+`ng ho+.p "fraud", nhu+ng pha?i du`ng
> phu+o+ng pha'p khoa ho.c dde^? chu+'ng minh nhu+~ng
> "fraud" ddo' chu+' to^i chu+a tha^'y ai du`ng  LNBD
> dde^? la`m ddu+o+.c 

   To^i kho^ng tin nhu+~ng Fayerabend hay Kristeva cho
Sokal la` "khoa ho.c". Sokal la` khoa ho.c ngoa`i
nga`nh, ddo^'i vo+'i ho. chi? la` LNBD tho^i. Dda^y
kho^ng pha?i la` tranh lua^.n. View cu?a to^i kha'c
anh tho^i.
 
> To^i kho' co' the^? tha^'y co' nhu+~ng fraud hay
> lu+`a dda?o, gia? tri' gia? trong ca'c ta'c pha^?m
va(n ho.c

  Va^.y anh nghi~ phe^ bi`nh chi? co' nhie^.m vu. khen
tho^i hay sao? Va^.y phe^ bi`nh du`ng dde^? la`m gi`?

> Ddo^.c gia? se~ nha^.n ngay kho^ng ca^`n TMH hay
> nhu+~ng phe^ bi`nh gia du`ng LNBD. Thi. tru+o+`ng
> se~ loa.i bo? va` sa'ch kho^ng ai ddo.c.

  To^i cu~ng nghi~ the^'. Nhu+ng ca^u ho?i ho+i kha'c.
Kho^ng pha?i la` "ddo^.c gia? co' ca^`n...." ma` "TMH
va` phe^ bi`nh gia du`ng LNBD co' cha^'p nha^.n
ddu+o+.c tre^n thi` tru+o+`ng hay kho^ng". Cu~ng cu`ng
mo^.t logic ta.i sao la.i pha?i phe^ bi`nh ca'c nha`
phe^ bi`nh na`y. ta.i sao kho^ng dde^? cho "ddo^.c
gia? va` thi. tru+o+`ng loa.i bo?"
   
> OK. Nhu+ng to^i chu+a tha^'y la` vie^.c na`y dda~
> mang la.i ta'c du.ng to^'t.

   Co^' nhie^n anh co' the^? nho+' nhu+~ng ta'c pha^?m
to^'t dde^? la`m da^~n chu+'ng. Nhu+~ng ta'c pha^?m
do+? bi. loa.i mo^.t ca'ch thi'ch dda'ng thi` ai nho+'
la`m gi`. Nhu+ng to^i cho la` phe^ bi`nh pha?i co'
che^ khen. Ngay chuye^.n che^ Mme Chatterley to^i cho
cu~ng ca^`n thie^'t va` cha(?ng ha.i gi` ( nhu+ anh
dda~ tha^'y). Qua ddu+o+.c nhu+~ng phe^ bi`nh ddo'
ta'c pha^?m mo+'i chu+'ng to? ddu+o+.c gia' tri. Che^
sai ba^'t co^ng la` thu+o+`ng.
 
> Co' the^? to^i ca?m ti`nh vo+'i nhu+~ng ngu+o+`i o+?
> vi. the^' du+o+'i the^' ("underdog") trong nhie^`u
> ti`nh huo^'ng \. To^i cha('c ra(`ng ra^'t nhie^`u
> ngu+o+`i co' "thie^n vi." vo+'i nhu+~ng ngu+o+`i o+?
> the^' ye^'u co^' ga('ng vu+o+.t qua kho' kha(n
> hie^?m nghe`o \. Dda^y co' the^? la` LNDB :-)

  Dda^y la` chuye^.n kha'c, ngoa`i va(n chu+o+ng.
Anyway, to^i appreciate anh du`ng chu+~ LNBD kha'
ddu'ng :-))
 
> TMH dda~ chu? ddo^.ng la`m tru+o+'c

   Ta.i sao  pha?i ba('t chu+o+'c TMH. Pha?i cha(ng
anh phe^ pha'n TMH ve^` phong ca'ch, nay anh cu~ng
la`m theo thi` anh co`n raison d'e^tre gi` nu+~a. La`m
sao anh tha^'y ddu+o+.c ca'i sai cu?a TMH cu?a LNBD
khi anh la`m gio^'ng nhu+ the^'?

   To^i cho ta('c ti. la` o+? cho^~ ddo'. Anh ca^`n
hie^?u ddu'ng su+. xua^'t hie^.n va` die^~n bie^'n
cu?a LNBD, ddie^?m ma.nh, ddie^?m ye^'u cu?a no' mo+'i
co' the^? tra'nh ngo~ cu.t na`y. DDa(`ng na`y anh
LNBD, to^i cu~ng LNBD thi` to^i e kho^ng hie^.u qua?.

  No'i cho cu`ng thi` ai trong chu'ng ta cu~ng ma('c
be^.nh na`y mo^.t chu't. Co' lu'c cu~ng hay hay,
nhu+ng la^u thi` bi. lu+u manh ho'a. Tra'nh ddi la`
vu+`a ma(.c du` du`ng cu~ng khoa'i dda'o dde^? :-))

Cheers
Aiviet

   

   
 

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Bid and sell for free at http://auctions.yahoo.com