RE: DDa.i, tie^?u thu+`a

[Phan Anh Son <Phan@pgsm.hu>]

Hi ba'c La^m,

To^i kho^ng theo dda.o gi` ca? nhu+ng nghe ba'c no'i ve^` va^'n dde^`
Dda.o gia'o
nhie^`u ca'i ra^'t gio^'ng to^i nghi~ ne^n cu~ng muo^'n than gia va`o
dde^` ta`i na`y 
 
>Tha`nh ra Dda.o (hay Cu+'u ca'nh) co' dda^'y, nhu+ng kho^ng the^?
>du`ng ly' lua^.n hay du`ng ba^'t cu+' ca'i gi` dde^? chu+'ng minh la` no'
>co' dduo+.c. Cho ne^n ne^'u pha?i nho+` nguo+`i kha'c ba?o cho Cu+'u 
>ca'nh la` ca'i gi` dde^? ma` ddi to+'i thi` ho?i ca'i dduo+.c ba?o
>ddo' co' co`n la` Cu+'u ca'nh nu+~a hay kho^ng?

Theo to^i du`ng logic dde^? chu+'ng minh co' dda.o hay kho^ng la`
nonsense.
Da.o thi` thie^n ve^` ca'i ta^m, logic thie^n ve^` ca'i dda^u`. Ca? hai
the^' gio+'i
dde^`u self-contained ca?. Vi' nhu+ hi`nh ho.c A'csimet vo+'i hi`nh ho.c
Lobanoszky
dde^`u ddu'ng ca?, chi? kha'c nhau la` cho^~ xua^'t pha't la` tie^n
dde^` so^' 5 tho^i.
 
>Muo^'n tha^'y dduo+.c Dda.o pha?i du`ng ca'i phuo+ng pha'p ma` thu+.c ra
>la` "kho^ng phuo+ng pha'p", tu+'c la` kho^ng du`ng gi` ca?. Tu+. Dda.o no'
>dde^'n vo+'i ta, uy.ch mo^.t ca'i, tru+.c tie^'p, nhu+ nhie^n, to'm la.i
>la` du`ng ngo^n ngu+~ (1 phuo+ng tie^.n) dde^? mo^ ta? ca'i su+. ga(.p
>Dda.o na`y la` kho^ng the^? dduo+.c. 


Vi` va^.y ma` ca'c Zen master chi? da.y ho.c tro` ngo^i` thie^`n va`
tra? lo+`i
ca'c ca^u ho?i ba(`ng ca'c "kungan", nghi~a la` ba(`ng ca'c paradox ma`
logic
tho^ng thu+o+`ng kho^ng hie^?u no^?i, gia^.t ngu+o+`i ta ra kho?i ca'i
vo`ng
lua^?n qua^?n cu?a logic

Nha^n tie^.n ho^m tru+o+'c ba'c A'iVie^.t no'i dda('c da.o co' nhie^`u
giai ddoa.n,
to^i co' ddo.c trong mo^.t cuo^'n sa'ch no'i ngu+o+`i Nha^.t co' bo^.
tranh 10
bu+'c no'i ve^` ca'c giai ddoa.n dda('c da.o cu?a Zen:

Tranh 1: Ngu+o+`i no^ng da^n ma^'t tra^u, ti`m cuo^'ng le^n o+? kha('p
no+i,
vi' nhu+ ngu+o+`i mo+'i theo dda.o, bo^? cho^~ na`y, cho^~ kia kho^ng
co'
mu.c di'ch

Tranh 2: Ti`m tha^'y ve^'t cha^n tra^u: Tha^'y a'nh sa'ng cuo^'i
ddu+o+`ng ha^`m
Da^'u cha^n gia'n ddoa.n, khi co', khi ma^'t.

Tranh 3: Ca^`m ddu+o+.c so+.i da^y xa^u o+? mu~i tra^u, Nhu+ng no' vu`ng
va(`ng ma.nh la('m. Da^y la` giai ddoa.n dda^'u tranh ma.nh nha^'t

Tranh 4: Tha('ng ddu+o+.c con tra^u, da('t no' ve^` nha`. 

Tranh 5: Ngo^`i le^n lu+ng tra^u, ca^`m cu+o+ng.
Ddu+o+`ng ddi ddo+~ me^.t ho+n.

Tranh 6: Kho^ng ca^`n pha?i ca^`m da^y, tra^u tu+. ddi. Anh no^ng da^n
tho^?i sa'o

Tranh 7: Tra^u mang ve^`, buo^.c o+? nha`: Kho^ng co`n lo dda.o so^?ng
ddi ma^'t

Tranh 8: Anh no^ng da^n ddi bo^., kho^ng tha^'y tra^u dda^u: DDa.o dda~
bie^'n va`o
ma'u thi.t, kho^ng co`n pha^n chia nu+~a.

Tranh 9: Anh no^ng da^n tre^n ba~i co?, hoa tho+m, co? dde.p

Tranh 10: Anh no^ng da^n va`o tha`nh pho^', ddi giu+~a cho^'n ddo^ng
ngu+o+`i:
Dda('c dda.o dde^'n mu+'c so^'ng giu+~a ddo+`i ma` bu.i kho^ng ba'm.


Ba'c na`o co' y' kie^'n gi` ve^` ca'c giai ddoa.n a^'y kho^ng?

Cheers,

Son,
 
>